You and I (Metropolitan Playhouse)

A young man dreams of a career as a painter but falls in love.  Instead of pursuing his passion, he marries and becomes a businessman for a company that makes soap.  In his forties and looking back, he realizes as an individual he was an “I.”  As a married man, however, it’s always “You and I.”  What makes for a happy life?  A fulfilling one?  What are the compromises and benefits associated with signing on to “you and I”?

This play’s plot also revolves around their son who dreams of a career as an architect.  Like his father, he has fallen in love at a young age.  Go to Europe and study or get married?  The set up occurs early in this diverting, uncomplicated story.  Philip Barry wrote this play while he was engaged and trying to establish himself as a playwright before settling down.  The axiom “write what you know” certainly applies here.

A critical and commercial success, You and I was Mr. Barry’s first play to be produced on Broadway in 1923.  His later and more famous works include Holiday and The Philadelphia Story (written specifically for Katherine Hepburn) which were turned into Hollywood films.  You and I was also adapted into a now lost 1931 movie called “The Bargain.”

Metropolitan Playhouse explores America’s theatrical heritage to illustrate contemporary American culture.  Do you follow a path to your passions which may be less lucrative than getting a safer job in business?  That is certainly a question being addressed by young people today.  You and I explores that theme with the added fun of listening to language, mannerisms and societal hierarchies now a century old.

In a small off-off Broadway house, this company has mounted a fine, well-directed (Michael Hardart) version of this play.  The cast is quite accomplished in portraying roles from this very old play without any smell of mothballs.  Finely etched characterizations were created by Elisabeth Preston (as the mother) and Aidan Eastwood (as her son).  In particular, her chemistry with her husband (an excellent Timothy C. Goodwin) was believable and had a cool, nicely understated Nick and Nora vibe.

Caitlyn Barrett’s set design is simple and highly effective in establishing place.  The scene changes are performed by the actors in this very intimate space.  The overall result is an evening spent eavesdropping in a family’s home as they ponder the mini-dramas of the day.  I enjoyed this production of You and I immensely.  Glad to see this rarely revived play on stage and highly recommend a trip to the Metropolitan Playhouse in the East Village.  And while you are there, check out my favorite Cuban restaurant in New York City, Café Cortadito, just two blocks away!

www.metropolitanplayhouse.org

www.cafecortadito.com

theaterreviewsfrommyseat/amarriagecontract/metropolitanplayhouse

A Lovely Sunday for Creve Coeur (La Femme Theatre)

One of Tennessee Williams’ final plays, A Lovely Sunday for Creve Coeur, was first produced in 1979, four years before he died.  This piece is rarely revived.  The relatively new company La Femme Theatre has a mission to celebrate and explore the universal female experience.  As an added bonus, one of my favorite performers, the usually hilarious and talented Kristine Nielsen (Hir, Vanya and Sonia and Masha and Spike) costars.

Creve Coeur is a park located in St. Louis.  The setting is a small working class apartment in 1937.  Bodey (Ms. Nielsen) shares her apartment with Dorothea (Jean Lichty), a high school civics teacher with more than a crush on the school principal.  The play opens with her waiting for a promised phone call from him.  She is classically written in the Blanche DuBois mold; fading beauty and delusional dreamer.  Every Sunday, Bodey packs a lunch to go to Creve Coeur with a not-so-subtle attempt to fix Dorothea up with her slovenly brother.

Despair, desperation and loneliness are key themes in this work.  Miss Gluck (Polly McKie) is the deeply grieving upstairs neighbor who has just lost her mother and is living alone.  The kind-hearted Bodey is consoling her with coffee and crullers every day.  Dorothea cannot deal with Miss Gluck’s depressed countenance, hysterical crying and aggressive ranting in her native German.  Dorothea’s coworker Helena (Annette O’Toole) makes a surprise visit and her haughtiness sparks conflict with Bodey’s calculated kindness and sets the tone for an exercise in verbally eviscerating combat.

A Lovely Sunday for Creve Coeur is a tragicomedy with four meaty roles for actresses to play.  The meanness of women (especially to each other) is certainly on display here but with added layers of fear, dreams, self-protection and gut instincts.  Everyone is damaged; some have more highly developed coping skills.  The performances are mixed.  Ms. Nielsen’s tragic moments are heart wrenching in their emotional availability.  Her comedic line readings are directly from the “Best of Kristine Nielsen” playbook.  Fans know what that means.  Here it occasionally registers a bit too big but admittedly this play has slow moments to fill.

Ms. Lichty and Ms. McKie nicely inhabit their very different roles despite the nuttiness of the plotlines.  Ms. O’Toole’s characterization of the highfalutin Helena seemed quite starchy for my tastes; too one dimensionally prim for all the harshness written into the role.  The play is unabashedly kooky so these actresses have to traverse massive mood swings.  Creve Coeur is a long one act piece and the tempo dragged a number of times.  Austin Pendleton directed these ladies to play the scenes fairly bluntly.  Oddly the set designer (Harry Feiner) and the director were out of synch.  Sometimes there would be eavesdropping near the imaginary door between rooms.  Other times these women directly confronted each other face to face over furniture where there had recently been an imaginary wall.

There are good reasons to see A Lovely Sunday in Creve Coeur, particularly if you enjoy Tennessee Williams.  Last spring, Classic Stage Company (with the Transport Group) mounted an outstanding version of Summer and Smoke.  His plays are rich with imperfect souls.  If you come to see this production, sit very close to the front.  Some lines were hard to hear in Row A.  I understood why people in the back were complaining on the way out.  For emotionally scarring melodrama to work, it has to be audible.

www.lafemmetheatreprodutions.org

theaterreviewsfrommyseat/summerandsmoke

Ripcord (Elkhart Civic Theatre, IN)

After a successful home win at Notre Dame against Vanderbilt, I decided to take a drive and check out the Elkhart Civic Theatre, a community troupe in Indiana which performs in the historic, and quite nice, Bristol Opera House.  Ripcord, written by David Lindsay-Abaire, is their first production of this year’s season.  I saw this playwright’s Pulitzer Prize winning Broadway play Rabbit Hole in 2006.  In that piece, a tragic event looms like a dark cloud over a family but there are also elements of comedy.  In Ripcord, the same duality exists but not quite as heavy, nor as deep.

Directed by Demarée Dufour-Noneman, this slightly dark situation comedy might be appropriately titled Golden Girls With a Vengeance.  Two ladies share a room in the Bristol Place Senior Living Facility.  Abby Binder (an assured Jenny DeDario) is, frankly, a pain in the ass and cannot seem to get along with others.  Enter Marilyn Dunne, the chatty one with the seemingly sweet simple demeanor.  The two concoct a bet.  Can Abby be scared?  Can Marilyn get mad?  Down the rabbit hole they go as the pranks intensify.

Marilyn may have a sweet nature but there is a strong fortress of self-protection lurking underneath the somewhat batty exterior.  She is well-played by Stacey Nickel who ensures that we have empathy for her as well as mild repulsion.  All of this is light as air dark comedy.  There is meanness for sure but it skims along quickly and is forgotten as we move onto the next series of hijinks.

The Elkhart Civic Theatre has given Ripcord a solid production.  The pacing is just right for the material and the set design effectively accomplishes a lot of scene changes with its modest budget.  The skydiving scene was cleverly executed.  In multiple roles, Keith Sarber was memorable, notably as Benjamin, the character who helps ground the plot toward its Golden Girls finale.  All in all, an entertaining production of this play by everyone backstage and onstage.  Kudos to the company for having bios in the program for the crew.

John Shoup is this theater’s Artistic and Technical Director.  In his letter from this season’s brochure, he eloquently encapsulates this company’s DNA.  “You see, this is theatre – for and by the community.  Over the years, thousands of people have had a hand in creating characters and whole worlds that once existed only in a playwright’s imagination – here, in this place, on our stage.  This is where we become family, whether it’s for a few weeks or a few generations.  This is where we do what we love – and share what we love – in the hope that you will love it, too.”

Is there a better way to express the passion and purpose of localized community theater?  I look forward to seeing another production at the Elkhart Civic Center one day.  Because I love it too.

www.elkhartcivictheatre.org

Days to Come (Mint Theater)

Lillian Hellman’s second Broadway play was a one week flop titled Days to Come.  It followed her triumphant The Children’s Hour and was staged prior to oft-revived The Little Foxes.  In his 1936 review for the New York Times, famed critic Brooks Atkinson wrote “it is a bitter play, shot through with hatred and written with considerable heat.”  Noted for presenting lost and forgotten works, this play is getting another look at the Mint Theater Company.

Mr. Atkinson did write that this drama was “elusive” and that is certainly the case.  Days to Come is about the wealthy Rodman family in Callom, Ohio, a small town of Cleveland.  They have owned a brush factory for multiple generations.  The workers have gone on strike and the play begins with the hiring of strikebreakers.  Thugs is a proper description.  The weak leader of the clan is Andrew (Larry Bull) who clearly has marital issues with his frequently disappearing wife Julie (Janie Brookshire).

Much of the play seems centered around family dynamics which include spinster sister Cora, played with appropriate jitters and indignation by Mary Bacon.  She collects and rearranges figurines in between belittling the servants.  The family lawyer and Andrew’s lifelong friend and advisor seems to have a hand in everything.  Naturally the thugs spark some predictable drama and tensions in the town escalate.

On the side of the workers is a Leo Whalen (Roderick Hill) who earnestly advises the strikers who are led by family loyalist Thomas Firth (an excellent Chris Henry Coffey).  Back and forth we journey from the factory strike angle to the broader family drama.  The dialogue seemed forced and not quite natural.  At first I thought the uneven acting might be to blame but the play is thematically unfocused so that could be the inherent problem.  What I loved about Days to Come is that Ms. Hellman does not really take a side for or against the family or the strikers.  Everyone sort of loses here and perhaps that is why Mr. Atkinson called her play “bitter.”  I felt the inconclusive gray area to be most interesting aspect of her writing.  Otherwise, this revival is mildly thought provoking and mediocre.

www.mintheater.org

Red Emma and the Mad Monk (The Tank)

Once in a blue moon (or should I now say red?) you take in a new work off-off Broadway and walk out of the theater wholly impressed.  Such is the feeling generated by the musical Red Emma and the Mad Monk being presented this month at The Tank.  Writer Alexis Roblan and Director Katie Lindsay co-created this original and ambitious piece composed by Teresa Lotz.  Twelve year old Addison is in her room doing the usual internet surfing and tweeting.  Addison is also a history buff.  The show is set in the United States in 2017 “where the 19th, 20th, and 21st centuries exist side by side, online and in a theatre.”

Addison has an imaginary best friend in the Russian mystic Grigori Rasputin who elevated himself from poverty to holy man.  Or is that charlatan?  This monk was a healer to the last tsar’s son prior to the Russian revolution and all of their assassinations.  She is also obsessed with Emma Goldman, the writer who was a pivotal figure in the development of anarchist political philosophy in the early 20th century.  Along with her lover Sasha Berkman, they planned but failed to murder steel industrialist and union-buster Henry Clay Frick in support of the worker’s movement.

Incidentally, Addison also has her own young person’s life crises to manage.  What emerges from this richly conceived phantasmagoria is much more than a history lesson juxtaposed with school age internet drama.  Red Emma and the Mad Monk confronts the politics, trials and tribulations that lead to anarchies both large and small.  This musical contemplates the internet, our news cycle and oppressive systems of government by imaginatively combining and contrasting these stories.  Complexity is embraced and analyzed.  What is the best way to make change?  Is there a best way?

Now for the cherry on top.  Surprisingly, Red Emma is funny and very entertaining.  Drita Kabashi’s performance as Rasputin is light as air yet mystical and substantial, filled with thoughtful, sometimes hilarious observations on life.  (Her eyes should have a curtain call.)  As Addison, Maybe Burke believably grounds this story so we experience thought processes from a twelve year old’s point of view.  In multiple important roles, Jonathan Randell Silver was spot on in each characterization.

The creative team did truly inspired work in mounting this production, notably the set design by Diggle.  When you enter the theater, you immediately feel that you are in a young person’s bedroom.  The lighting, costumes and, in particular, the direction of Red Emma and the Mad Monk inventively showcased this unique musical.  So many topical themes and ideas poured from the stage.  America is and may always have been the promise of freedom but that doesn’t necessarily happen in practical terms.  Some impressive new voices in theater worth a serious listen.

www.thetanknyc.org

Fairview (Soho Rep)

When exiting the theater after Fairview has come to an end, my first reaction was a need for reflection time.  Jackie Sibblies Drury has written a shockingly fascinating big broad comedy that is structurally dissonant (for lack of a better term).  I will not spoil the enjoyment of this play for anyone.  Ms. Drury has serious observations to share on the subject of race.  How we think about race.  How race is used for entertainment.  How race is divisive.  How human beings are all the same underneath a layer of skin.

Fairview begins as an African American family comedy.  It’s Grandma’s birthday and her daughter is throwing a bash at her house.  Her demanding and critical sister arrives.  Her husband is helping her get ready but her stress level is so high she cannot relax.  The family revels in the fact that they are known for dancing.  Dancing does indeed happen and the entire family’s spirit soars together, if only for that moment.  Familial comedies with bite are common.  What makes Fairview so unique are the layers that get added on and then multiply.

Sarah Benson’s direction is assured.  This is a complicated, absorbing piece of theater which respects the audience but forces them to think outside the box.  Raja Feather Kelly choreographed Fairview and her work has a big impact.  The entire cast miraculously balances caricature and farce with layered dimensions of depth and realness.  But the playwriting is the star here.  Ms. Drury has many surprises up her sleeve.  I won’t spoil them and you should not miss them.  This play is a co-production with Berkeley Rep which will present Fairview in October.

www.sohorep.org

www.berkeleyrep.org

Southern Gothic (Windy City Playhouse, Chicago)

The program informs you that “You’re Invited” to the birthday celebration of Mrs. Suzanne Wellington on June 30, 1961.  Mr. Beau Coutier and Mrs. Ellie Coutier are hosting the party at their home in Ashford, Georgia.  The telephone rings.  The caterers have been in a traffic accident.  Heavens to Betsy!  What shall we do?  Leftover jello salad in the fridge can be repurposed!  No need to panic, however, as the booze appears to be plentiful.  Although Virginia Woolf has not been invited to this party, in Southern Gothic her spirit is alive and well.

When entering the theater at the Windy City Playhouse, as an invited guest you are entering the Coutier home.  You sit on the perimeter (or stand) in the kitchen, living room, dining room, whatever suits your fancy.  This is immersive theater and you are free to move around.  The 28 audience members are silent but visible witnesses to the comings and goings of four couples who have scintillating melodrama bubbling close to the surface.  Introduce alcohol and let’s find out who’s a thief, who’s a philanderer and who gets a dish best served cold.

The ingenious set design by Scott Davis is a remarkable time capsule.  The kitchen in particular is classic formica and stainless steel 1950’s perfection.  (I want to buy the table when the run is over.)  As voyeurs, follow various parts of this story, some of which occur in different rooms simultaneously.  You already surmise that our birthday girl gets sloppy drunk.  She’s not alone.  Everyone has significant personal dramas, some self-induced, some the product of living in the South during this era.

The skilled performances are impressively focused  given that the audience is in such close proximity.  Drinks are even handed out should you want to toast Mrs. Wellington.  My pick for Best in Show would be the charmer politician Charles Lyon (played by an ideally cast Victor Holstein).  Or maybe the slightly simple Beau Coutier (Michael McKeough)?  Can’t forget his jittery wife Ellie (Sarah Grant).  Never mind, all eight actors shine brightly (or vividly flame out in a supernova implosion) as needed.  Written by Leslie Liautaud, Southern Gothic is a terrific entertainment given a memorable staging by director David H. Bell.

www.windycityplayhouse.com

The Boys in the Band

In 1968, The Boys in the Band opened off-Broadway and ran for 1,001 performances before being turned into a movie.  At the time, the play was revolutionary for its depiction of gay men on stage.  Considered groundbreaking, the opinions of this piece vary.  Some viewed the portrayals as “self-homophobic, low esteem characters.”  Others saw the play as a coming out of the closet for the gay rights movement that followed.  For its 50th anniversary, The Boys in the Band has been revived on Broadway with a cast of openly gay actors.

Michael (Jim Parsons) is hosting a birthday party for his best friend Harold (Zachary Quinto).  The party banter is bitchy shade before alcohol and pot open some serious wounds.  Think Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf? with extra sharp knives.  The catalyst for the drama is Michael who has been trying to stay off the bottle.  A surprise visit from his college roommate has him trying to control the boys into acting straight.  Hard to do when one of the birthday gifts is a hustler dressed as the Midnight Cowboy.  A party game drama unfolds and then explodes.

The laughs are in huge supply as are the depths of anguish.  The play confronts the hatred and self-deprecation faced by some homosexuals head on.  Some found the picture painted too bleakly.  The story is indeed rough but, like it or not, there are characters in this play fifty years later who still ring true.  The Boys in the Band is a period piece for sure.  Joe Mantello’s strong directorial hand and the entire cast’s finely detailed performances add color and nuance to the words giving us a staging worth celebrating.

A year after this play was first produced, the Stonewall Riots occurred and the gay liberation movement took shape.  While The Boys in the Band flirts with gay stereotypes and aggressively embraces negative emotions, it’s existence is undeniably important to the history of LGBT rights in America.  For that reason alone, the play is essential viewing.  The fact that this revival is so good is a happy 50th birthday bonus and a beacon for continuing forward (not backward) down the yellow brick road toward tolerance and freedoms for all.

www.boysintheband.com

Straight White Men (Second Stage Theater)

If you desire to see the oddest preshow at a Broadway house, then Straight White Men should be on your list.  The music is thump, thump, thump party loud.  A woman apologizes to audience members and hands out earplugs if you want them.  The elderly folk seem annoyed.  The woman promises that the music will turn off at the start of the play and will never come back on but the reason it’s playing so loud will make sense.  I won’t spoil the surprise by telling you the reason.  It does makes some sense.  It has absolutely nothing to do with the play that follows.  Odd is the word for this overly forced exercise in lecturing.

Speaking of forced, Straight White Men is about three brothers and a father spending Christmas together.  These are the most liberal white men in the history of the universe.  Their deceased mother repurposed their Monopoly game as one called “Privilege.”  The brothers seem very close and typical familial memories are shared and reenacted.  At their age, the physical antics don’t seem entire credible but they are very funny.  The comedic part of this play works very effectively.  Armie Hammer (Call Me By My Name) and Josh Charles (The Antipodes) are two of the brothers and they deliver top notch laughs.  This play works best as a comedic sendup of upper middle class white guys having a jolly time.  Older brother Matt’s childhood anthem protesting the all-white casting of Oklahoma at his grade school is truly memorable.

Unfortunately, we have a serious issue lurking not too far under the surface.  Matt (Paul Schneider) has taken a life turn and is now living at home with Dad.  Everyone is analyzing him out loud.  One theory is that he recognizes his white privilege and is purposely setting his career aside so that a non-white individual can have his opportunity in life.  Did I say the most liberal family ever?  I did indeed.  This half of the story is, at best, mildly interesting.  At it’s worst, the dialogue is stilted and strains credibility.  Did the playwright Young Jean Lee shoot for intellectual farce?  The therapy section is played very seriously though so the story turns odd, like the opening preshow.  Maybe that’s the connection?  Apparently straight white men are imperfect people too so feeling sorry for them is now allowed?  Half a really funny play doesn’t quite make up for the other half which is exaggerated baloney.

www.2st.com

The Damned

At one point during Ivo van Hove’s production of the interestingly creative yet maddeningly tortoise-paced production of The Damned, a crucial line appears in English supertitles.  “The complicity of the German people is the miracle of the Third Reich.”  A headline in today’s New York Times:  “As Trump Struggles With Helsinki’s Fallout, Congress Faces a New Charge:  Complicity.”  A very interesting time for this piece to be showcased in the large Park Avenue Armory space in collaboration with the Comédie-Française who premiered this work at the Avignon Festival in 2016.

The Damned is a renowned 1969 film by Luchino Visconti.  It was nominated for a Best Screenplay Oscar and named Best Foreign Film by the National Board of Review.  The plot centers around the Essenbeck family and their steelworks business as Adolph Hitler is coming to power in 1930’s Germany.  The story is a thinly veiled reference to the Essen-based Krupp family of steel industrialists.  A soap opera that would make the TV show Dynasty blush, The Damned has murders, double crossings, incest, child molestation, a homosexual orgy and a row of coffins placed on the side of a massive set.

The play begins with the 1933 burning of the Reischtag (home of the German parliament) one month after Hitler became Chancellor.  Building on anti-communist hysteria, the event was immediately politicized.  Hitler convinced President Hindenburg to issue a decree suspending most civil liberties including freedoms of expression, the press, the right of public assembly, as well as eliminating the secrecy of the post and the telegraph.  Four months later Hitler carried out a series of political executions in order to consolidate his power.  The subjects of those attacks were the SA (Storm Troopers), millions of whom helped the Nazi’s rise to power since the 1920’s.  The leader of the SA was Ernst Rohm whose brutish behavior, heavy drinking and homosexuality offended conservative elements.  The Night of the Long Knives is portrayed as a stylized orgy scene before turning into a bloody execution.

Using a camera, the play is also projected on a large screen.  There are close-ups and historical footage used effectively to enhance the storytelling.  My reaction was appreciation for creativity rather than a total embrace.  The pacing was deliberately very slow.  The repeating processions to the coffins was visually arresting the first time, with diminished results thereafter.  The orgy scene was indulgent and would have had the same impact in half the time.  If The Damned was a half hour shorter, I believe it would have been just as stylized without also being plodding.

The subject matter, however, is beyond intriguing for today’s audiences.  A politician rising to power attacking established personal freedoms, including the press.  A political party embedding itself with the armament business.  A warning that the complicity of people led to the end of democracy and the rise of the Third Reich.  The play ends spectacularly.  I walked out of the theater pondering how the tale of America at the beginning of the 21st Century will be told eighty years from now.

www.armoryonpark.org